Summary
In a Manitoba feeding trial, steers on forage testing 127 RFV gained 2.74 lb a day. Steers of the same starting weight on 101 RFV forage gained 0.88 lb a day, and by the end of the trial the two groups were 184 lb apart per head.
The better forage also took 10.5 lb of feed per pound of gain, compared with 18.2 lb on the poorer forage. That's why higher-quality hay can cost more per ton and still produce cheaper gain, up to a certain price. This post works through where that price is and what the difference is worth over a winter.
What the Manitoba trials found
The figures below come from Backgrounding Calves With Manitoba Forage, published by the Manitoba Forage and Grassland Association.
The first trial, run at Beausejour in 2000, fed steers a forage-only ration: alfalfa and alfalfa/grass round-bale silage, plus mineral, salt and vitamins A, D and E, with no grain. Four forage quality levels were fed in the same pens over the same period.
| Forage RFV | Starting weight | Finishing weight | Average daily gain | Feed per lb of gain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 101 | 669 lb | 757 lb | 0.88 lb | 18.2 lb |
| 125 | 667 lb | 870 lb | 2.13 lb | 11.6 lb |
| 127 | 666 lb | 941 lb | 2.74 lb | 10.5 lb |
| 142 | 668 lb | 885 lb | 2.17 lb | 11.1 lb |
The steers started within three pounds of each other and finished 184 lb apart.
A second set of trials at the University of Manitoba, feeding baled silage that was chopped before feeding, showed the same pattern:
| Forage quality | ADG | Feed per lb of gain |
|---|---|---|
| RFV 100 (low) | 2.0 lb | 8.5 lb |
| RFV 125 (medium) | 2.8 lb | 6.8 lb |
| RFV 130+ (high) | 3.6 lb | 5.4 lb |
The absolute numbers differ, which is expected with chopped feed and a different feeding setup, but the relationship holds. Across both trials, the report puts gains on all-forage diets at roughly 1.25 to 2 lb a day or more, depending on forage quality.
Feed per pound of gain
Average daily gain gets most of the attention, but feed conversion is what decides whether better hay pays for itself.
In the Beausejour trial, the RFV 101 group needed 18.2 lb of feed for each pound of gain, and the RFV 127 group needed 10.5 lb. The better forage took about 42% less feed to put on the same pound.
Two things drive that. The first is digestibility. Lower-RFV forage has more fibre and less energy, so less of what the animal eats ends up as gain. The second is intake. High-fibre hay fills the rumen and moves through slowly, so cattle can't eat enough of it to make up the difference. They end up eating less and converting it worse, which is how a gap of about 25 RFV points turned into nearly 2 lb a day of gain.
Comparing two loads on price per ton alone leaves most of that out.
What it costs at $200 a ton
Take lower-grade hay at $120/ton and premium hay at $200/ton, and apply the conversion figures from the trial:
| Low-RFV hay (101) | Premium hay (127) | |
|---|---|---|
| Price per ton | $120 | $200 |
| Price per lb | $0.060 | $0.100 |
| Feed per lb of gain | 18.2 lb | 10.5 lb |
| Feed cost per lb of gain | $1.09 | $1.05 |
At these prices the better hay comes out four cents ahead per pound of gain, which is a narrow margin.
The breakeven is about $208 a ton. Above that, the better hay no longer wins on feed cost per pound of gain. At $240 a ton, for example, the conversion advantage doesn't cover the higher price.
On that measure alone, $200 hay is close to even. But most people feed to a date rather than to a target weight, and that changes the comparison.
Over a 120-day winter
Backgrounding calves usually means feeding from freeze-up to grass. The number of days is set, and the calves weigh whatever they weigh at the end of it.
Here are the same two hays over 120 days:
| Low-RFV hay (101) | Premium hay (127) | |
|---|---|---|
| Average daily gain | 0.88 lb | 2.74 lb |
| Gain over 120 days | 106 lb | 329 lb |
| Feed consumed | ~1,920 lb | ~3,450 lb |
| Feed cost at the prices above | $115 | $345 |
| Weight off a 600 lb calf | 706 lb | 929 lb |
The better hay costs $230 more per head and puts on 223 more pounds, so each extra pound costs about $1.03.
The finishing weights matter on their own too. A calf coming off at 706 lb sells into a different market than one at 929 lb, and if the plan was to background and sell into a spring market, the lighter calf hasn't gained much ground.
Is a pound of gain worth more than $1.03?
Current prices from Saskatoon Livestock Sales, week of November 10, 2026:
| Weight class | Steers ($/lb) | Heifers ($/lb) |
|---|---|---|
| 600 lb | 5.21 – 5.90 | 4.49 – 5.42 |
| 700 lb | 4.90 – 5.30 | 4.30 – 4.67 |
| 800 lb | 4.40 – 4.65 | 4.15 – 4.45 |
| 900 lb | 4.20 – 4.55 | 3.85 – 4.25 |
Heavier cattle sell for less per pound, so the extra 223 lb can't be valued at a single price. The price slide takes back part of the gain.
Estimating a price for each finishing weight from the ranges above:
- The 706 lb calf is worth roughly $3,576
- The 929 lb calf is worth roughly $3,984
- The extra 223 lb is worth about $407, or $1.83 a pound after the slide
With the extra gain costing $1.03 a pound, that leaves roughly $180 per head after paying for the better hay, or about $18,000 on 100 head.
A couple of caveats. Auction ranges are wide, and where your cattle sell within them depends on quality, lot size and the sale. The market is also softer than it was. Canfax reported 550 lb Alberta steers at $643.77/cwt for the week ending October 30, about $48 below the same week last year, and notes that heavier steers have typically dropped about 5% from October to December over the five-year average. Feeding into a falling market reduces the return, so it's worth running the numbers with your own prices.
Where more RFV stops paying
Higher RFV doesn't always mean more gain. In the first trial, the RFV 142 forage produced 2.17 lb a day, less than the 2.74 lb on RFV 127. In the University of Manitoba trials, the RFV 150+ group gained 2.2 lb a day against 2.3 lb for the RFV 130 group. In both cases the highest-testing forage didn't produce the most gain.
Very high RFV usually means early-cut, highly digestible forage that passes through the rumen quickly and carries little effective fibre. In a backgrounding ration with no grain or straw, that can affect rumen function, and the extra energy on the feed test doesn't show up as gain.
For backgrounding cattle on a forage-only ration, RFV of about 125 to 140 looks like the useful range. Higher-testing hay makes more sense when it's balanced with lower-quality roughage or fed to stock that can use it, such as high-producing dairy cows.
Our hay tests between 130 and 170 RFV. For backgrounding, the lower end of that range is usually the better fit. For lactating dairy cows, the higher end is.
Wintering a cow herd
For a cow herd, forage quality shows up in body condition rather than daily gain, and body condition affects the following year.
Feed values from Saskatchewan Agriculture's Beef Cow Rations and Winter Feeding Guidelines:
| Feed | TDN | Crude protein |
|---|---|---|
| Alfalfa-grass hay | 60.0% | 14.0% |
| Grass hay | 62.3% | 10.7% |
| Slough hay | 53.1% | 7.2% |
| Cereal straw | 45.0% | 4.2% |
The guidelines note that straw-based rations don't supply enough energy during lactation, and that low-quality straw can cause impaction, especially after a sudden cold snap.
Targets from the same guidelines:
- Keep cows at a body condition score of 3 to 3.5 on the five-point scale
- A cow in good condition still needs to gain 150 to 180 lb over winter to cover the calf and the calf bed
- Thin cows need to gain weight over winter, which takes good or average-quality forage plus supplemental grain or pellets, not straw
- In the 60 days before calving, cut roughage by about 15% and raise grain or pellets by about 15%
- Limit-fed cows need forage dry matter at roughly 1% of body weight per day
The guidelines also note that underfeeding affects body condition and can lead to poor performance in the breeding herd. A cow that calves thin tends to breed back later, which shows up as a longer calving season and lighter calves the following fall.
Testing your forage and building the ration around what it's missing is the best place to start. We can include a feed analysis with any load.
Running your own numbers
The same method works with your own figures:
| Step | What to enter | Our example |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Days you will feed | Freeze-up to grass | 120 days |
| 2. Expected ADG on each hay | From the feed test and the tables above | 0.88 lb / 2.74 lb |
| 3. Total gain | Step 1 × step 2 | 106 lb / 329 lb |
| 4. Feed needed | Step 3 × feed per lb of gain | 1,920 lb / 3,450 lb |
| 5. Feed cost | Step 4 × your price per lb | $115 / $345 |
| 6. Extra cost of the better hay | Difference in step 5 | $230 |
| 7. Extra pounds | Difference in step 3 | 223 lb |
| 8. Cost per extra pound | Step 6 ÷ step 7 | $1.03 |
| 9. Value per extra pound | Sale value at both finishing weights, divided by the pounds between them | $1.83 |
| 10. Net return | Step 9 minus step 8, × step 7, × head count | ~$180/head |
For step 9, use the price for the weight class your cattle will finish at, not the class they're in now. Otherwise the price slide is left out and the better hay looks better than it is.
It also helps to have a feed test. An analysis gives you crude protein, ADF, NDF, TDN and RFV. Without one, the ADG in step 2 is a guess and the rest of the calculation is built on it. Every load we sell can come with an analysis.
Use the delivered price in step 5. Freight on hay adds up, so the number should include getting it to your yard.
Limits of these numbers
These were silage trials, not dry hay. The Beausejour and University of Manitoba trials fed round-bale and chopped baled silage, and dry hay behaves differently in storage and at the bunk. The relationship between quality and gain should hold, but don't expect exactly 2.74 lb a day.
The moisture basis isn't stated. The source tables don't say whether feed per pound of gain is on a dry matter or as-fed basis. That changes the absolute costs but not the comparison, since the same adjustment applies to both hays. On a dry matter basis, $1.09 and $1.05 become roughly $1.24 and $1.19, and the better hay is still ahead by about the same margin.
RFV is only part of the picture. It's calculated from ADF and NDF and says nothing about protein, minerals or mould. Some nutritionists prefer RFQ or milk per ton for that reason, so it's worth reading the full analysis.
This is one trial. Four pens at one site in one year is evidence, not proof. It's included here because it's Prairie data on Prairie forage and agrees with the University of Manitoba work, but your cattle, weather and bunk management will all affect the result.
We sell alfalfa hay, so it's reasonable to check our arithmetic. Every figure in this post is linked to its source below.
Sources
All sources were current as of November 12, 2026.
| Figure used | Source |
|---|---|
| RFV vs. ADG and feed conversion (Beausejour 2000 trial; University of Manitoba chopped silage trials); 1.25 to 2 lb/day forage-only gain range | Backgrounding Calves With Manitoba Forage, Manitoba Forage and Grassland Association |
| TDN and crude protein of alfalfa-grass hay, grass hay, slough hay and cereal straw; body condition score targets; 150 to 180 lb winter gain; 1% of body weight intake; pre-calving ration shift; straw and lactation warning | Beef Cow Rations and Winter Feeding Guidelines, Saskatchewan Ministry of Agriculture |
| Feeder steer and heifer prices by weight class, week of November 10, 2026 | Saskatoon Livestock Sales market report |
| 550 lb Alberta steers at $643.77/cwt, week ending October 30, 2026; year-over-year comparison; October to December price slide on heavier steers | Canfax cattle market report, via The Western Producer |
| Relative feed value definition and calculation | Determining Relative Feed Value, Government of Saskatchewan |
Market prices in this post will change from week to week.
Ballek Farms Ltd. has grown hay east of Outlook, Saskatchewan since 1904, on more than 2,900 irrigated acres in the Lake Diefenbaker district. Our alfalfa tests 20%+ protein and 130 to 170 RFV, and every load can come with its analysis.
See current inventory and delivery, or call 306 867 7053.
